
Judgement relates to 2004 case in which Belgacom unit was ordered to filter traffic. Internet service providers (ISPs) cannot be made to install monitoring systems to prevent illegal downloads of copyrighted material, Europe's highest court said Thursday. The judgment relates to a 2004 case, where SABAM, a Belgian company which manages the copyrights of Belgian writers and composers, took Internet service provider Scarlet Extended to court in Belgium complaining of illegal downloads of music by its customers. The court ordered Scarlet, a unit of telecom company Belgacom SA, to install a filter that would check through all its online traffic so as to make illegal downloads impossible. Scarlet appealed the decision to the Brussels Court of appeal which sought the ECJ's opinion on how the matter affects EU law, according Total telecom.
"EU law precludes an injunction made against an Internet service provider requiring it to install a system for filtering all electronic communications passing via its services which applies indiscriminately to all its customers, as a preventive measure, exclusively at its expense, and for an unlimited period," the Luxembourg-based European Court of Justice (ECJ) said in a statement.
Click here to find out more!The ECJ said that while intellectual property rights are enshrined in EU law, there is "nothing whatsoever... to suggest that right is inviolable." It also said that maintaining a system to constantly monitor what was being downloaded would be highly expensive for ISPs and affect their freedom to conduct business. It also conflicted with the right of Internet users to have their private data and information protected.
While the practice of filtering all content was shot down by the court, there are similar, less intrusive schemes in other EU countries. France put in a place a new antipiracy law in October, known as Hadopi, under which people who illegally download films receive warning emails before facing court and a year-long suspension from their Internet connection.
ISPs welcomed the decision. The European Internet Services Providers Association (EuroISPA), an industry body which represents 1800 ISPs across Europe, said the decision will have serious implications for content blocking systems imposed on ISPs in certain countries.
"Considering the major contribution that the Internet industry can make to the economic recovery, it was indeed not the time to put the innovation of the Internet at risk," Malcolm Hutty, President of EuroISPA said in a statement.
Record companies said that while this particular decision may have been rejected, the other systems across Europe are helping to protect online content.
Click here to find out more!"In this particular case, the court rejected the content filtering measure presented by the Belgian court as too broad," Frances Moore, CEO of record industry trade body IFPI said in a statement."However, this does not affect the forms of ISP cooperation that IFPI advocates including graduated response and the blocking of rogue websites, which are already being implemented in countries across Europe."





