.

Lumbering, querulous, and struggling to make progress. No, not European leaders – European telecoms companies. This sector may be the third best-performer this year, on a total return basis, after healthcare and energy. But it has posted a gain of just 0.03 per cent since the start of 2011, compared with 9.66 per cent decline for the Bloomberg European 500 generally, according Financial Times. All things are relative.

Investors’ desire for safety notwithstanding, whether Europe’s telcos can keep up even this pace is questionable. The sector’s relative outperformance following the 2008 crisis proved fairly shortlived, fading as the outlook improved. That pattern could repeat itself. Revenues, for a start, are under pressure as European consumers confront austerity, especially in southern Europe. This is prompting many telcos to cut their prices. While Eurozone communications prices have been falling throughout the past five years, those declines became less steep in 2009 and 2010. Now, though, the pricing situation is deteriorating again, Barclays Capital reckons.

Regulators are not helping, either: European telecoms commissioner Neelie Kroes, for example, sent a frisson round the industry when she suggested recently that access charges to lucrative copper networks, largely owned by former state monopolies, could be curbed if their owners failed to invest in high-speed broadband facilities.

Investors may also worry that the sector could be vulnerable to snatches by cash-strapped, debt-laden governments, whether in the form of direct taxes, stake sales or spectrum auctions. And then there is the yield issue. To date, commitments, generally made before 2008, have kept dividend pay-outs and yields high, on average 8-9 per cent. Pay-outs range from about two-thirds to well over 100 per cent of free cash flow. But as the pressure for high-speed networks – and hence more capital expenditure – increases, the requirement to reinvest more funds will surely increase. Investors should pitch their expectations accordingly.